In the comments to yesterday's post about Kashchei Immortal, I noticed differences in opinions about who better played the image of the main villain of Russian fairy tales. The survey in that post, I forgot to do. Therefore, it is necessary to correct a separate post. And at the same time I will ask you about another popular scum, which I mentioned earlier
I will not do the analysis of the candidates anymore, we will manage to refer to yesterday’s publication - Kashchei Immortal in Russian cinema fairy tales
We turn immediately to the survey. Since Kashchei George Millyar turned out to be very different, in the survey they are presented separately
Poll # 2074039 The best of many Russian cinema
Open to: All , detailed results viewable to: All . Participants: 362
Best Kashchey
View answers
George Milyar ("Kashchey the Immortal", 1944)
151 ( 41.7 % )
Yevgeny Lebedev (Rimsky-Korsakov, 1953)
0 ( 0.0 % )
George Milyar ("Fire, water and ... copper pipes", 1967)
50 ( 13.8 % )
Fedor Nikitin ("Funny magic", 1969)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Nikolai Boyarsky ("The New Year Adventures of Masha and Viti", 1975)
5 ( 1.4 % )
Alexander Filippenko ("There, on unknown paths ...", 1982)
101 ( 27.9 % )
Oleg Tabakov ("After the rain on Thursday", 1986)
34 ( 9.4 % )
Victor Sergachev ("Sitting on the Golden Porch", 1986)
2 ( 0.6 % )
Igor Yasulovich ("Lilac ball", 1987)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Valery Ivchenko ("The Tale of the Painter in Love", 1987
0 ( 0.0 % )
Anatoly Smiranin ("The Legend of the Bane or In Search of the Thirtieth Kingdom", 2004)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Alexey Petrenko ("The Legend of the Bane or In Search of the Thirtieth Kingdom", 2004)
1 ( 0.3 % )
Nodar Mgaloblishvili ("Miracles in Reshetov", 2004)
3 ( 0.8 % )
Gosha Kutsenko ("The Book of Masters", 2009)
1 ( 0.3 % )
Evgeny Schetinin ("Adventures in the Thirtieth Kingdom", 2008)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Leonid Yarmolnik ("The Real Tale", 2011)
9 ( 2.5 % )
Konstantin Lavronenko ("The Last Knight", 2017
5 ( 1.4 % )
Well, in order not to run twice, at the same time let's choose the best Baba Yaga (although here, as a result of the vote, I do not even doubt). The analysis of the candidates is presented in the publication Baba Yaga in domestic cinema. By analogy with Kashchey, Baba-Yagi Georgy Millyar in the survey are presented separately
Poll # 2074040 Best Baba Yaga of the national cinema
Open to: All , detailed results viewable to: All . Participants: 283
Best Baba Yaga
View answers
Georgy Milyar ("Vasilisa the Beautiful", 1939)
68 ( 24.0 % )
Georgy Milyar ("Frost", 1964)
137 ( 48.4 % )
George Milyar ("Fire, water and ... copper pipes", 1967)
19 ( 6.7 % )
Zinovy Gerd ("At the Thirteenth o'clock in the Night", 1969)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Valentina Sperantova (Merry Magic, 1969)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Maya Bulgakova ("Lada from the country of Berendey", 1971)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Georgy Milyar (Golden Horns, 1972)
1 ( 0.4 % )
Valentina Kosobutskaya ("The New Year Adventures of Masha and Viti", 1975)
16 ( 5.7 % )
Maria Barabanova ("How Ivan the Fool Went to the Miracle", 1977)
1 ( 0.4 % )
Tatiana Peltzer ("There, on unknown paths ...", 1982)
32 ( 11.3 % )
Svetlana Kharitonov ("The Purple Ball", 1987)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Alexander Lenkov ("The Island of Rusty General", 1988)
5 ( 1.8 % )
Maria Mashkova ("The Legend of Kashchee or In Search of the Thirtieth Kingdom", 2004)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Lia Akhedzhakova ("The Book of Masters", 2009)
2 ( 0.7 % )
Anna Yakunina ("Adventures in the Tentieth Kingdom", 2008)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Lyudmila Polyakova (The Real Fairy Tale, 2011)
0 ( 0.0 % )
Elena Yakovleva ("The Last Knight", 2017)
2 ( 0.7 % )
Sources ... ] Sources
Photo from www.rian.com.ua/photolents/20131107/3390 25969.html
The article is based on materials .
Comments
Post a Comment